Yep, this is how schools kill creativity

poetry gene Phil Nel

So you’re a high school student. At that time in your life, maybe you’re writing poetry about lots of darkness and death, or maybe you’re a football player who gives little thought to anything inside the classroom.

Emily Dickinson 1Or, okay — let’s ditch the stereotypes. Say you’re a football player who writes a poem with actual emotion behind it. That’s more than a lot of people can do when they’re being forced to churn out a poem for a grade. To the untrained, creativity — writing — isn’t something that can be done on command, without the spark of inspiration.

But one high school football player from Rittman, Ohio actually channeled his thoughts and feelings (in this case, frustration) into his poetry assignment — and he got punished for it. The 16-year-old Nick Andre wrote about his team’s losing season and how the star wide receiver gets more perks than he should because he’s the coach’s son and quarterback’s friend. Andre titled his poem “Stupid.”

Emily Dickinson 2The school called it “hazing” and “harassment,” suspended him for four days, and made him sit out the last two games of the season.

Andre’s response is actually smart, which isn’t surprising considering what he did with his poem. “Who am I harassing or hazing?” he told local news. “I mean, I didn’t state any names.

“It’s like wow, just over doing my school work, I get in trouble, get thrown off the football team, you know get suspended for four days, which could potentially really mess up my grades” (emphasis mine).

So this is how schools kill creativity — by misinterpreting it as misbehavior. It’s like the kid in the back of the class who draws nasty pictures of his teacher, but the art is really, really good. Should that be confiscated and discouraged, or should the teacher make an exception? The difference to a future could be huge.

God forbid a kid write a poem and like it.

5 thoughts on “Yep, this is how schools kill creativity

  1. captainkwerk

    This reminds me of the recent Steubenville and Maryville, Missouri rape cases. I know it’s not exactly the same, and I’m not equating this to rape at all, but these small towns take their football seriously. The common denominator on all of these is that one person threatened football. (Before anyone gets offended, I’m from a small town myself and know how crazy small towns can be about sports)

    1. Stephanie Carmichael

      I absolutely agree with you. People are way too serious about sports at schools — or sports in general. I live in a major city, and I went to one game recently (not my usual thing, but I was with a friend), and it’s crazy.

      So I think the problem is part pride over football, part strict school rules … They don’t want to make an exception because then they’d be making an exception for everything. It’s dumb, but I sort of get that. But I think it was definitely an overreaction to suspend him or punish him at all for what he wrote. He didn’t name names, and he did the assignment with gusto. He might stir up a little controversy among his friends, but the kid didn’t do anything wrong.

  2. valerierlawson

    what’s worse is that this kid was venting some negative feelings in a creative and healthy way and was then told in no uncertain terms “this is bad”. that’s so infuriating.

Tell me something!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s